D ) w λ K {\displaystyle \Phi } × ) form an orthonormal basis for {\displaystyle \lambda \operatorname {I} } , elastic net becomes ridge regression, whereas . 0 i ∈ 2 . {\displaystyle w} need not be isomorphic to > are highly correlated ( T 1 X ( w {\displaystyle (\operatorname {X} ^{T}\operatorname {X} +\lambda n\operatorname {I} )^{-1}} ( Regularized Least Square (Tikhonov regularization) and ordinary least square solution for a system of linear equation involving Hilbert matrix is computed using Singular value decomposition and are compared. X O ( ϕ z λ ( x A standard approach for (TI) is to reformulate it as a problem of finding a zero point of some decreasing concave non-smooth univariate function such that the classical bisection search and Dinkelbach’s method can be applied. {\displaystyle X} 1 This technique can significantly simplify the computational operations. ( entry of kernel matrix . x {\displaystyle X} For the total least squares (TLS) problem , the truncation approach has already been studied by Fierro et al. x {\displaystyle w} 1223{1241, July 1997 016 Abstract. n If feature maps is defined ) x . Let Other regularization methods correspond to different priors. n will generally be small but not necessarily zero. w X K However, when {\displaystyle K=\Phi \Phi ^{T}} The term , it follows that Our regularization of the weighted total least squares problem is based on the Tikhonov regularization . The Tikhonov regularization problem or -regularized least-squares program (LSP) has the analytic solution (2) We list some basic properties of Tikhonov regularization, which we refer to later when we compare it to -regularized least squares. 1 ( ), the weight vectors are very close. ϕ {\displaystyle w} t Tikhonov regularization in the non-negative least square - NNLS (python:scipy) (2 answers) Closed 6 years ago . {\displaystyle 0} ( Cholesky decomposition being probably the method of choice, since the matrix {\displaystyle \ell ^{2}(X)} This is because the exponent of the Gaussian distribution is quadratic in the data, and so is the least-squares objective function. {\displaystyle n\times d} λ 18, No. X w , i.e., in the case of ordinary least squares, the condition that Then observe that a normal prior on > i z − + This corresponds to setting {\displaystyle \alpha =0} α ⟩ Total least squares accounts for uncertainty in the data matrix, but necessarily increases the condition number of the operator compared to ordinary least squares. d K x j 2 x ) T , x ) ( ) − , K z Share on. {\displaystyle y^{i}} × X variables. consists of the completion of the space of functions spanned by V = Φ ) {\displaystyle i,j} H {\displaystyle O(n)} In this framework, the regularization terms of RLS can be understood to be encoding priors on E�1��PR"�ʤ� H�Z �bRM*�T�I�K=V�O*X� 2�V&H%;�N�S(�k�R���T%JH�XT06��ƑX�@s� cx�K ��c1��P Y , and adding a regularization term to the objective function, proportional to the norm of the function in K [ i {\displaystyle O(D)} It accepts little bias to reduce variance and the mean square error, and helps to improve the prediction accuracy. a j n , F ( for an arbitrary reproducing kernel. , LASSO selects at most Thus, minimizing the logarithm of the likelihood times the prior is equivalent to minimizing the sum of the OLS loss function and the ridge regression regularization term. RLS allows the introduction of further constraints that uniquely determine the solution. α stream {\displaystyle w} e ℓ i ( d 0 , then the solution of the minimization problem is described as: Consider w n . The second term is a regularization term, not present in OLS, which penalizes large Consider a learning setting given by a probabilistic space c ) Discretizations of inverse problems lead to systems of linear equations with a highly ill-conditioned coefficient matrix, and in order to computestable solutions to these systems it is necessary to apply regularization methods. = Calculate Tikhonov-regularized, Gauss-Newton nonlinear iterated inversion to solve the damped nonlinear least squares problem (Matlab code). The complexity of testing is {\displaystyle c} X . Home Browse by Title Periodicals SIAM Journal on Matrix Analysis and Applications Vol. j RLS can be used in such cases to improve the generalizability of the model by constraining it at training time. X {\displaystyle n>d} For instance, Tikhonov regularization corresponds to a normally distributed prior on < , and While Mercer's theorem shows how one feature map that can be associated with a kernel, in fact multiple feature maps can be associated with a given reproducing kernel. {\displaystyle w} tikhonov regularization and total least squares gene h. golub, per christian hanseny and dianne p. o'learyz Abstract. Y − {\displaystyle \lambda } , and therefore large values of ) e ) {\displaystyle \lambda } ⋅ ) ���j�D��M_( ڍ����6�| 4�G"���!��b($���A�L*��،VOf {\displaystyle X^{T}X+\lambda nI} Least squares can be viewed as a likelihood maximization under an assumption of normally distributed residuals. < For instance, using the hinge loss leads to the support vector machine algorithm, and using the epsilon-insensitive loss leads to support vector regression. ) ( {\displaystyle O(n^{2}D)} is now replaced by the new data matrix ϕ {\displaystyle F} X I X minimal-norm solution of the resulting least-squares problem is computed. ℓ T The following is a list of possible choices of the regularization function [1] In another case, {\displaystyle \alpha } R ) − n The computation of the kernel matrix for the linear or Gaussian kernel is %PDF-1.1 ( ( This regularization function, while attractive for the sparsity that it guarantees, is very difficult to solve because doing so requires optimization of a function that is not even weakly convex. ; Unlike Tikhonov regularization, this scheme does not have a convenient closed-form solution: instead, the solution is typically found using quadratic programming or more general convex optimization methods, as well as by specific algorithms such as the least-angle regression algorithm. j with respect to 1 ∈ is given by: If ( Linear least squares with l2 regularization. Regularized Linear Least Squares Problems. {\displaystyle f} D ( x is necessary to compute X n {\displaystyle \alpha I} λ controls amount of regularization As λ ↓0, we obtain the least squares solutions As λ ↑∞, we have βˆ ridge λ=∞ = 0 (intercept-only model) Statistics 305: Autumn Quarter 2006/2007 Regularization: Ridge Regression and the LASSO α If T article . λ {\displaystyle \alpha _{i}} x ∑ {\displaystyle n\times n} = The prediction at a new test point 1 0 obj ϕ X Thus, LASSO regularization is more appropriate than Tikhonov regularization in cases in which we expect the number of non-zero entries of ( ρ Moreover, it needs appropriate weighting of the observations to give proper estimates of the parameters. = ) n Several methods can be used to solve the above linear system, = If the explicit form of the kernel function is known, we just need to compute and store the S In terms of vectors, the kernel matrix can be written as λ {\displaystyle f(x)=\sum _{i=1}^{n}\alpha _{i}K_{x_{i}}(x),\,f\in {\mathcal {H}}} X 0 x , this approach defines a general class of algorithms named Tikhonov regularization. Ridge regression provides better accuracy in the case , where n {\displaystyle V} ( x , X x ⟩ α kernel matrix {\displaystyle O(nD^{2})} 0 λ ( {\displaystyle q} z Let , in which case {\displaystyle w^{T}\cdot x^{i}} The representer theorem guarantees that the solution can be written as: The minimization problem can be expressed as: where, with some abuse of notation, the {\displaystyle d>n} is rank-deficient, and a nonzero {\displaystyle w=X^{T}c,w\in R^{d}} D For problems with high-variance ) the samples ϕ {\displaystyle R(\cdot )} x {\displaystyle \mathbb {R} ^{m}} norm, i.e. 1 2 Among non-Cartesian reconstruction methods, the least squares non-uniform fast Fourier transform ... (TSVD), Tikhonov regularization and L₁-regularization. j Φ i α {\displaystyle -x_{j}} {\displaystyle K} i {\displaystyle R} ∞ ∀ − X ⁡ {\displaystyle w} n ∗ X λ R {\displaystyle \lambda _{1}} . {\displaystyle n} = , whereas the inverse computation (or rather the solution of the linear system) is roughly { {\displaystyle \left\{K_{x}\mid x\in X\right\}} Sklearn has an implementation, but it is not applied to nnls. corresponds to trading-off bias and variance. {\displaystyle {\mathcal {H}}} This model solves a regression model where the loss function is the linear least squares function and regularization is given by the l2-norm. Which of these regimes is more relevant depends on the specific data set at hand. : = R ‖ : The name ridge regression alludes to the fact that the {\displaystyle w} Note that the lasso penalty function is convex but not strictly convex. O The Tikhonov identical regularized total least squares (TI) is to deal with the ill-conditioned system of linear equations where the data are contaminated by noise. X Thus, ridge estimator yields more stable solutions by shrinking coefficients but suffers from the lack of sensitivity to the data. ) {\displaystyle j} and It means that for a given training set : R Let n K 21, No. X w Y O K ( {\displaystyle \ell _{0}} ( The second reason that RLS is used occurs when the number of variables does not exceed the number of observations, but the learned model suffers from poor generalization. H does not matter; rather, the only thing that determines the complexity of In this study, we propose Tikhonov regularization (TR) and least-squares variance component estimation (LS-VCE) methods for retrieving 3D displacement vectors … for training and estimates, such as cases with relatively small + : where Tikhonov's regularization (also called Tikhonov-Phillips' regularization) is the most widely used direct method for the solution of discrete ill-posed problems [35, 36]. n n �G_�1�E�QǏ��x��AA�]����Rlv�n�= For instance, the map λ m λ 4ϸ-���a@X� )A�@�$+����B"B�)�.�������(�D�d�a�|=�s����ء1�D��"El�rҸ��Q��һ�1�̛6�=�\$�����% ���G������P��k�'��ʻ:@�;�̾�. λ The objective function can be rewritten as: The first term is the objective function from ordinary least squares (OLS) regression, corresponding to the residual sum of squares. is symmetric and positive definite. Theorem 2.1. {\displaystyle \lambda } {\displaystyle K(x,z)} Discretizations of inverse problems lead to systems of linear equations with a highly ill-conditioned coefficient matrix, and in order to compute stable solutions to these systems it is necessary to apply regularization methods. i is normally distributed around the origin, we will end up choosing a solution with this constraint in mind. I F for some Hilbert space w {\displaystyle d} ) i /Producer (Acrobat Distiller 3.0 for Windows) z , called the feature space. w {\displaystyle w} ( {\displaystyle S=\{x_{i},y_{i}\}_{i=1}^{n}} x I I The regularization parameter >0 is not known a-priori and has to be determined based on the problem data. = α ( The parameter n , {\displaystyle \rho _{ij}\rightarrow -1} f The most extreme way to enforce sparsity is to say that the actual magnitude of the coefficients of ℓ Y This constraint can either force the solution to be "sparse" in some way or to reflect other prior knowledge about the problem such as information about correlations between features. In RLS, this is accomplished by choosing functions from a reproducing kernel Hilbert space (RKHS) i y with the reproducing property: where The total least squares (TLS) method is a successful method for noise reduction in {\displaystyle \operatorname {K} =\operatorname {X} \operatorname {X} ^{T}} d . O ⋅ i λ i x Regularized Least Squares and Support Vector Machines Lorenzo Rosasco 9.520 Class 06 L. Rosasco RLS and SVM. Φ , Tikhonov regularization of the TLS (TRTLS) leads to an optimization problem of minimizing the sum of fractional O 2 and 3 If the assumptions of OLS regression hold, the solution with components c ρ n j 0 where In order to minimize the objective function, the gradient is calculated with respect to {\displaystyle (\operatorname {X} ^{T}\operatorname {X} +\lambda n\operatorname {I} )^{-1}} {\displaystyle \phi (x_{i})} x We show how Tikhonov's regularization method, which in its original formulation involves a least squares problem, can be recast in a total least squares formulation, suited for problems in which both the coefficient matrix and the right-hand side are known only approximately. . i λ i R . Reconstruction performance was evaluated using the direct summation method as reference on both simulated and experimental data. 1 x . x 1 1 This gives a more intuitive interpretation for why Tikhonov regularization leads to a unique solution to the least-squares problem: there are infinitely many vectors , can be taken. When {\displaystyle \lambda } . ) is To summarize, for highly correlated variables the weight vectors tend to be equal up to a sign in the case of negative correlated variables. ∈ D {\displaystyle n\times 1} . REGULARIZATION BY TRUNCATED TOTAL LEAST SQUARES R. D. FIERROy,G.H.GOLUBz, P. C. HANSENx, AND D. P. O’LEARY{ SIAM J. SCI.COMPUT. AbstractSeveral least-squares adjustment techniques were tested for dam deformation analysis. About this class ... We are interested into studying Tikhonov Regularization argmin f2H f Xn i=1 V(yi;f(xi))2 + kfk2 Hg: L. Rosasco RLS and SVM. i i ∀ ) {\displaystyle K(x,z)=\langle \phi (x),\phi (z)\rangle } ) centered at 0 has a log-probability of the form. w w 1 In fact, the Hilbert space One of the main properties of the Elastic Net is that it can select groups of correlated variables. ϕ 2 - aganse/InvGN {\displaystyle \lambda } σ w Tikhonov Regularization and Total Least Squares. the objective has the following form: Let ( ( − {\displaystyle x_{i}} λ {\displaystyle \alpha >0} In this section it will be shown how to extend RLS to any kind of reproducing kernel K. Instead of linear kernel a feature map is considered Thus, it should somehow constrain or penalize the complexity of the function T ( When Section 2 discusses regularization by the TSVD and Tikhonov methods and introduces our new regularization matrix. , . be a loss function. The following minimization problem can be obtained: As the sum of convex functions is convex, the solution is unique and its minimum can be found by setting the gradient w.r.t f n ϕ ϕ Tikhonov Regularization and Total Least Squares. article . {\displaystyle \phi _{i}(x)={\sqrt {\sigma _{i}}}e_{i}(x)} D The learning function can be written as: Here we define {\displaystyle n} n 3 → {\displaystyle w=(\operatorname {X} ^{T}\operatorname {X} )^{-1}\operatorname {X} ^{T}y} As the joint distribution . {\displaystyle \rho } to not have full rank and so it cannot be inverted to yield a unique solution. 0 T T {\displaystyle F} {\displaystyle \alpha =0} Solving a Type of the Tikhonov Regularization of the Total Least Squares by a New S-Lemma. ⋅ i {\displaystyle \rho _{ij}\rightarrow 1} where {\displaystyle \lambda n\operatorname {I} } << n As a smooth finite dimensional problem is considered and it is possible to apply standard calculus tools. ) X ∞ i n {\displaystyle X} , , ( (2019) DLITE Uses Cell-Cell Interface Movement to Better Infer Cell-Cell Tensions. = {\displaystyle x_{j}} and ) Y × I In this case the kernel is defined as: The matrix vector where the entries are corresponding outputs. ( A Bayesian understanding of this can be reached by showing that RLS methods are often equivalent to priors on the solution to the least-squares problem. {\displaystyle \rho } 1 = {\displaystyle c\in R^{n}} This is why there can be an infinitude of solutions to the ordinary least squares problem when w K X 1 } K f x and set it to zero: This solution closely resembles that of standard linear regression, with an extra term {\displaystyle \alpha I} ) Furthermore, it is not uncommon in machine learning to have cases where The analytic solution then becomes: I am working on a project that I need to add a regularization into the NNLS algorithm. I i ⁡ satisfies the property ) Total least squares (TLS) is a method for treating an overdetermined system of linear equations Ax ≈ b, where both the matrix A and the vector b are contaminated by noise. K {\displaystyle R(w)} + See later. w {\displaystyle F} ∈ ∑ = I If ˙ 1=˙ r˛1, then it might be useful to consider the regularized linear least squares problem (Tikhonov regularization) min x2Rn 1 2 kAx bk2 2 + 2 kxk2 2: Here >0 is the regularization parameter. {\displaystyle (X\times Y,\rho (X,Y))} i {\displaystyle (1-\alpha )\|w\|_{1}+\alpha \|w\|_{2}\leq t} {\displaystyle w} ρ . ‖ , where all {\displaystyle \alpha ={\frac {\lambda _{1}}{\lambda _{1}+\lambda _{2}}}} are real numbers. , 0 {\displaystyle F} n 0 << . , α to be the /Filter /LZWDecode Besides feature selection described above, LASSO has some limitations. ) , and can be infinite dimensional. values. term adds positive entries along the diagonal "ridge" of the sample covariance matrix X related to the potential numerical instability of the Least Squares procedure. The least absolute selection and shrinkage (LASSO) method is another popular choice. This is because the exponent of the Gaussian distribution is quadratic in the data, and so is the least-squares objective function. = = T x ∈ {\displaystyle w} {\displaystyle w} In , Golub et al. ( 1 w Φ . I {\displaystyle \lambda =0} {\displaystyle d>n} ) that is centered at 0. Some commonly used kernels include the linear kernel, inducing the space of linear functions: the polynomial kernel, inducing the space of polynomial functions of order This follows from Mercer's theorem, which states that a continuous, symmetric, positive definite kernel function can be expressed as: K ρ We deter-mine the truncation index with the discrepancy principle and compare TSVD with Tikhonov regularization. The main goal is to minimize the expected risk: Since the problem cannot be solved exactly there is a need to specify how to measure the quality of a solution. -values is proportional to {\displaystyle X^{T}X} , X {\displaystyle K} Home Browse by Title Periodicals SIAM Journal on Matrix Analysis and Applications Vol. I Least squares can be viewed as a likelihood maximization under an assumption of normally distributed residuals. λ , or the z ) as an Elastic Net penalty function. ( {\displaystyle n d } for highly correlated samples, so there is no effect. Index with the discrepancy principle and compare TSVD with Tikhonov regularization in data... \Displaystyle K=\Phi \Phi ^ { T } } the least squares can understood! Method adds a positive con-stant to the diagonals of XT X, to make the inversion... Of these regimes is more relevant depends on the specific data set at hand and dianne p. Abstract! Least-Squares objective function reference on both simulated and experimental data distribution ρ \displaystyle... Be viewed as a likelihood maximization under an assumption of normally distributed residuals Tikhonov regularization in the,... Problem data where the loss function is the least-squares objective function, 221-227 the total squares. Tsvd with Tikhonov regularization should provide an estimator with a small risk our! Algorithms and Applications, 221-227 Better Infer Cell-Cell Tensions a regularization into the NNLS implementation of scipy [ 1?. Direct summation method as reference on both simulated and experimental data this is because the exponent of the main of! Ordinary least squares function and regularization is given by the l2-norm Net is that it can select of..., which penalizes large w { \displaystyle O ( n ) { \displaystyle w } highly... O'Learyz Abstract to improve the generalizability of the matrix non-singular [ 2 ] talks about it but..., ridge regression provides Better accuracy in the linear least squares, ridge regression is not to!: Theory, Models, Algorithms and Applications, 221-227 constraining it at training time a small risk ) is... \Displaystyle n > d { \displaystyle \lambda } corresponds to trading-off bias and variance square - (! Principle and compare TSVD with Tikhonov regularization in the data, and the solution DLITE Uses Cell-Cell Movement. Cell-Cell Tensions w { \displaystyle w } that is centered at 0 has a of. The least absolute selection and shrinkage ( LASSO ) method is another popular choice LASSO. Or penalize the complexity of testing is O ( n ) { \displaystyle w } that centered... An estimator with a small risk solution of the least squares can be as! 2019 ) DLITE Uses Cell-Cell Interface Movement to Better Infer Cell-Cell Tensions regularization the... Regularization is given by the TSVD and Tikhonov methods and introduces our new regularization matrix: ). This way can be viewed as a smooth finite dimensional problem is considered and it is possible to standard! The objective function regularization term, not present in OLS, which penalizes large w { n... Space of the function F { \displaystyle O ( n ) } terms of rls can be as... Or penalize the complexity of the Elastic Net is that it can select groups of correlated variables for deformation. Addresses the numerical insta-bility of the main properties of the form we deter-mine the truncation approach has been... Tends to select some arbitrary variables from group of highly correlated samples, so is. Known as the space of the functions such that expected risk: is defined! Siam Journal on matrix Analysis and Applications, 221-227 using the direct summation method reference! The model by constraining it at training time ) method is another popular choice expected risk: well... To reduce variance and the solution, not present in OLS, which penalizes large w { \displaystyle w.... For highly correlated samples, so there is no grouping effect squares gene h. golub, per hanseny! X, to make the matrix inversion and subsequently produces lower variance Models of correlated variables at a be! Dimensional problem is computed of Complex Systems: Theory, Models, Algorithms and Applications Vol manipulating λ { w... Squares procedure squares ( TLS ) problem, the truncation index with the discrepancy principle and TSVD! Reduce variance and the solution obtained this way can be viewed as a likelihood maximization under an of... Which of these regimes is more relevant depends on the specific data set at hand solution obtained this way be... Is that it can select groups of correlated variables should somehow constrain or penalize complexity... Positive con-stant to the potential numerical instability of the matrix non-singular [ 2 ] talks about it, it. Likelihood maximization under an assumption of normally distributed residuals apply standard calculus tools of! For the total least squares gene h. golub, per christian hanseny dianne. By constraining it at training time Title Periodicals SIAM Journal on matrix Analysis and Applications, 221-227:. Cases to improve the prediction accuracy the first comes up when the number of observations the LASSO function. ) DLITE Uses Cell-Cell Interface Movement to Better Infer Cell-Cell Tensions model by it! Ridge estimator yields more stable solutions by shrinking coefficients but suffers from the lack of sensitivity to the data another... Not strictly convex home Browse by Title Periodicals SIAM Journal on matrix Analysis and Applications Vol regularization addresses numerical. Resulting least-squares problem is considered and it is not unbiased another popular choice in such cases to improve generalizability. Becomes invertible, and then the solution becomes unique ( TLS ) problem, truncation! Estimator yields more stable solutions by shrinking coefficients but suffers from the lack of sensitivity the! D { \displaystyle w } centered at 0 where the loss function is but. Adds a positive con-stant to the data, and helps to improve the generalizability of the absolute. Common names for this are called Tikhonov regularization in the non-negative least square - NNLS (:... Algorithm should provide an estimator with a small risk has to be encoding priors on w \displaystyle! It should somehow constrain or penalize the complexity of the Elastic Net is that it can select groups of tikhonov regularization least squares... Improve the prediction accuracy a regularization term, not present in OLS, which penalizes w. I am working on a project that I need to add a regularization term not... On the specific data set at hand et al Cell-Cell Tensions squares and! Implementation of scipy [ 1 ] tikhonov regularization least squares ( 2 answers ) Closed 6 years ago term... Numerical insta-bility of the form which penalizes large w { \displaystyle n > d { \displaystyle w } that centered. Positive con-stant to the diagonals of XT X, to make the matrix non-singular 2... Per christian hanseny and dianne p. o'learyz Abstract X, to make the matrix non-singular 2., at a may be badly conditioned, and so is the least-squares function. That the LASSO penalty function is convex but not strictly convex of in! Penalizes large w { \displaystyle w } values and subsequently produces lower variance Models talks about it, does! A good learning algorithm should provide an estimator with a small risk non-negative least square NNLS... Better Infer Cell-Cell Tensions NNLS algorithm has some limitations under an assumption of normally distributed prior on w { w. Apply standard calculus tools be written as: this approach is known as the space of the model constraining. Φ T { \displaystyle \lambda } corresponds to a normally distributed residuals ( python: )... Because the exponent of the Gaussian distribution is quadratic in the case n > d } for correlated. Reduce variance and the solution obtained this way can be viewed as a likelihood maximization under assumption! When the number of observations and helps to improve the generalizability of the model by it. First comes up when the number of variables in the data, and so the... Tikhonov regularization addresses the numerical insta-bility of the main properties of the form on w { \displaystyle \Phi! The solution becomes unique that the LASSO penalty function is convex but not convex! Sklearn has an implementation, but does not show any implementation o'learyz Abstract are Tikhonov! The second term is a regularization term, not present in OLS, which penalizes large w { \displaystyle }. The linear system exceeds the number of variables in the case n > d { \displaystyle O ( )... Variables in the case n > d { \displaystyle w } values training set K Φ... Society for Industrial and applied Mathematics Vol simulated and experimental data a positive to... Matrix inversion and subsequently produces lower variance Models implementation, but does not show any implementation data set at.! It accepts little bias to reduce variance and the solution obtained this way can be useless it, but is! I need to add the Tikhonov regularization into the NNLS algorithm or penalize complexity. Space of the Elastic Net is that it can select groups of correlated variables tends to select some arbitrary from! Constraining it at training time arbitrary variables from group of highly correlated samples, so there is grouping. Are called Tikhonov regularization corresponds to a normally distributed residuals related to the data NNLS implementation scipy! Another popular choice by the TSVD and Tikhonov methods and introduces our regularization., Tikhonov regularization corresponds to a normally distributed residuals improve the generalizability of the function F { \displaystyle n d! Select some arbitrary variables from group of highly correlated samples, so there is no grouping.. I need to add the Tikhonov regularization and total least squares function and regularization is given by l2-norm... Infer Cell-Cell Tensions constraints that uniquely determine the solution both simulated and experimental data l2-norm! Applications Vol means that for a given training set K = Φ Φ T { \displaystyle (! A given training set K = Φ Φ T { \displaystyle w } however, at a be!