If unicorns could make bagels, they’d look like this. But the store also has some unique spreads that are always on offer, like the jalapeño asiago. But we dug a little deeper into the heart of New York City bagel shops to reveal some of the most unusual and enticing spreads. There’s nothing terrible about this bagel, it just doesn’t taste as good as a plain bagel — and let's be real: is Bagel Day really the time to worry about calories? The oats add an interesting texture, at least? All the Best Bagel Flavors, Ranked 1. There’s no such thing as too much garlic, especially in Jersey, and there’s something very satisfying about that flavorful crunch on your bagel. Exotic Flavors… Apple Pie Bagel Marble Rye bagel Kalamata Olive bagel Jalepeño bagel French Toast bagel It’s an all out Pizza Party and you’re going to love it! But a bagel? The hearty flavors of this chocolaty-brown bagel compliment any type of deli meat. Image from The Bagel Nook . Yes, for this everything bagel pull apart bread you need some extra time, but it’s worth it because it tastes delicious. With flavors almost as rich as our history, we have a chip or crisp flavor guaranteed to bring a smile on your face. Oreo cream cheese we’ve heard of. Everything and plain bagels are basically tied for the most popular flavors, though I am going to rank... 3. They’re not cloyingly sweet, the raisins add a nice chewy texture and on the whole it’s a good change-up from the classic savory flavors. Cinnamon-Raisin. Kettle boiled and oven baked, it’s the best of both worlds and it’s glorious! It very well could be the bagels. You won’t be doing your breath any favors, but your taste buds will thank you. And even though cinnamon never did anyone any harm, I love the creamy, savory flavor association I have with bagels. View the Slideshow >> (Gallery by Mandy Hofmockel, MassLive.com) EASTHAMPTON -- Peanut butter chocolate chip, hot … I don’t. Don’t get me wrong, blueberries are great. Differently shaped than every other bagel with a dent in the middle as opposed to a hole, filled with onions, garlic and poppy seeds. But the Oreo bagel that’s actually stuffed with Oreos is venturing into some uncharted bagel territory. Select from our 22 hand-rolled New York bagel flavors or fresh bialys.Free Overnight Shipping anywhere in the Continental USA is always included! Comfort Bagel. The material on this site may not be reproduced, distributed, transmitted, cached or otherwise used, except with the prior written permission of Advance Local. This would probably be incredible with lox and cream cheese. You’re welcome. Call us old-fashioned, but it ain’t broke, don’t fix it. Don't @ me. I am both terrified of and concerned about what might come next. That being said, the flavor was delicious -- as good as any plain bagel I’ve ever had. Everything bagels are terrific. Everything bagels combine a variety of spices to create a unique … Shouts to the Quaker Oats man. Keep reading for my definitive ranking of the 11 most popular bagel flavors, from worst to best. Unique bagel flavors, croissants will be staples at Flour Child Bakery. Look for unique flavors, such as Cheddar Bacon, Jalapeno with Pepperjack, Cranberry Orange or Raspberry Crunch, featured in our “Monthly Specials.” Check out our Bagel-of-the-day everyday! There are classics and there are unconventional takes, but there can be only one best flavor. Most bagel delis use marble bagels to create a classic Reuben bagel sandwich with pastrami and mustard. These bagels never really taste like cinnamon to me, but I love them anyway. Black and White Truffle Burger Bagel If you’re going to get just one topping on a bagel, go with sesame seeds. Their cream cheese flavors are phenomenal and if you’re looking for unique flavors for a weekend brunch gathering, Bantam is your place. At Mister Bagel we whip only the finest and creamiest of cream cheeses. Plain. Bagel Sizing – Bagels are 5oz. Everything. Tandem Bagel Company bakes unique flavors in Easthampton. 11. It’s a bagel, It’s a bun – It’s a sticky bagel bun. So it’s no surprise that these are pretty darn excellent. This is the desired bagel shop size and makes for a very upscale appearance. Points for being creative, but this doesn’t really work as an everyday bagel. The oniony, garlicky goodness in the middle is all you need. Apple ‘n Spice Signature Bagel Flavors I WANT BAGELS! Plain bagels provide the perfect base for delicious cream cheese or sandwich fillings. Cranberry Dark Chocolate Chip And if you can’t pick between all the flavors of bagels, why not get a little bit of everything? It’s soft. A tad savory for certain tastes, but certainly a classic and visually appealing. There are certain bagels out there that make us want to run and hide, and certain cream cheese flavors that risk turning us off of cream cheese forever. Everything bagels are incredible! More Bagel Flavors. This is not the case. Buy Wholesale Tamba Juice eLiquids Tamba Juice is famous for smoothie eJuice/eLiquid products. All rights reserved (About Us). Apple ‘n Spice We think of this flavor as apple pie meets bagel and it’s a most spectacular marriage. The beaches are great and Bruce Springsteen is a legend, but c'mon. If we're being honest most places don't even have bagels, they just have gross chewy rolls imitating our bagels. Bagel Flavors – We maintain twenty-eight (28) bagel flavors which include unique and healthful tastes such as Whole Wheat, Honey Oat Bran, Eight Grain, Spinach, French Toast, Wheat Bran topped with Oats, and more. Oreo Bagel with Oreo Cream Cheese and Oreos The Bagel Nook, Freehold, NJ. More power to y’all. Perfect for everyone except vampires. So, it tasted pretty damn good. Jeremy Schneider | NJ Advance Media For NJ.com. Large Tandem Bagel Pack (13 Bagels & 2 Tubs of Cream Cheese) Bagel Flavors ... Powered by Create your own unique website with customizable templates. But close enough! It’s going to taste like a crappy Thomas’s bagel from the bread section of a grocery store. This hardness refers to the density of the bread in the end or perhaps, even the process through which the grain is turned into flour. We’ve got these flavors in the dough and outside the dough. What's the best part of living in New Jersey? I imagine hell to be a pile of salt bagels with no access to water. It’s sweet. You can’t go wrong with a plain bagel and cream cheese. Sesame, garlic, onion and salt on a bagel might not be logical, but it’s is the bar-none best bagel out there, with every flavor complimenting the next. I’m all for a hint of salt on an everything, but when it’s the only thing on a bagel it’s just so overpowering. Follow him on Twitter @J_Schneider. Cinnamon raisin bagels are popular among people with a sweet tooth. Except when it goes so, so wrong. These we can abide (cinnamon raisin just barely). But you don’t need one. While some bagel flavors are so good they make everything they touch turn to gold (ahem, everything bagels), others are in fact so terrible that accidentally ordering one can ruin your day, week, or even year (ahem, blueberry). Take all the goodness of an everything and add the richness of egg to the base. We start with the simplest of ingredients: flour and water and finish with a slow, cold ferment to develop that unique bagel flavor we crave. Not so much. Loved the texture, though bagel purists may scoff. Pepperoni Mozzarella Nicole Musa | NJ Advance Media for NJ.com, By Jeremy Schneider | NJ Advance Media for NJ.com. Flavors of the Middle East drizzle on and baked into this bagel. I have a friend who swears by peanut butter on a cinnamon raisin, which is just crazy enough to work. And of course for the perfect crackly chew, it has to be boiled before it’s baked! Too much hype, not enough flavor. Inspired by one of New York’s most popular chain of Bagel Shops, get ready for unique bagel flavors like Cinnamon Raisin and much more! Bagel Café Bakery Flavor List Big Apple Bagels 8115 E. US Hwy 36 Avon, IN 46123 Phone (317)272-6944 Fax (317)272-6192 Apple Strudel Asiago Sour Dough Blueberry Cheddar Herb Chocolate Chip Cinnamon Raisin Cinnamon Sugar Cinnamon Walnut Crunch Egg Everything French Toast Garlic Honey Oat Jalapeno Monterey Cheese Onion Plain Poppy Seed Get Started. Check out our unique flavors We want […] Bottom line, the everything bagel has the dominant genes in the equation and carries this bagel to respectability. When consumed as a bagel, expect a very weird yet interesting kind of flavor in your mouth. Delicious. They sell cream cheeses too! The seeds go everywhere (and get stuck in your teeth) but the subtle flavor is definitely pleasant. Nice crunch, and a nice warm flavor that compliments just about anything you put on it. Flavored bagels are great and all, but sometimes you just need the original. © 2020 Advance Local Media LLC. Everything Bagel Pull Apart Bread. The water that comes from the Catskills is what makes the bagel have its unique texture and flavor. Pepperoni Mozzarella Veggies are great in a cream cheese, but not in the bagel itself. Jeremy Schneider may be reached at jschneider@njadvancemedia.com. It doesn’t matter where you get a blueberry bagel. If you’re gonna go with a sweet bagel as opposed to a savory, you might as well lean into it. Try it and you’ll understand. Whoever invented this beautiful concoction deserves a Nobel Prize for peace at breakfast time. The novelty works for a little while, but it’s ultimately too much sweetness for a bagel. ... You can pile high flavored cream cheese in sweet... 2. Chocolate Chip Bagels. Only the real can relate to this one. Maybe we're biased but it's basically a fact: no other part of the country has bagels as good as ours — the only other state that comes close is New York. Community Rules apply to all content you upload or otherwise submit to this site. If you don’t, you’ll hate it. Natural fermentation. This unique and fascinating word stems from an old Bavarian term that translates into “hard” in the English language. All 23 bagel flavors that matter, ranked worst to best Updated May 14, 2019; Posted Jun 05, 2018 By Jeremy Schneider | NJ Advance Media For NJ.com If not, skip ahead. Solid choice, just not before a job interview or first date. We take pride in using the same cheese recipes since 1977. 13 Schmear Recipes to Upgrade Your Morning Bagel - Brit + Co It would be a beautiful world if one could order a bagel flavor on a whim and be just as pleased as if they had ordered a plain bagel. ABOUT. Unique Pretzel Bakery offers a variety of pretzel flavors and styles that are healthy, nutritious, and sure to please everyone in your family. Coated with Extra Virgin Olive Oil, infused with Lebanese Za'atar drizzled on this bagel creates a flavor and texture that will make you want more. They just don’t work in bagels. The flavors in the box are Hot Pretzel, Bleecker Street, and Buffalo, which is celery carrot bagel filled with buffalo chicken blue cheese cream cheese. A bagel and cream cheese is one of those classic combinations that can do no wrong in our eyes. Some people ease the guilt of carbo-loading by going whole wheat. This is a rare fail for the typically beloved chocolate chip. Go to a classic bagel shop in New York City and you’ll encounter pretty much the same varieties at each of them: plain, poppy, sesame, everything, pumpernickel, onion, and some more (relatively) newfangled ones like cinnamon raisin, whole wheat and garlic. Brilliant. Bagels flavored with chocolate chips give the perfect sweet-savory taste in these crunchy rolls. Find NJ.com on Facebook. Ever have a bacon egg and cheese sandwich on one? The Spannuth family has been baking pretzels since the late 1800s – for six generations and counting – following in the footsteps of our ancestor, William P. “Bill” Spannuth. They're also a tad softer than standard bagels, and make for a great bacon egg and cheese starter. You may kind of feel like a horse eating this one, but it isn’t the worst thing you'll ever chew. Nicole Musa | NJ Advance Media For NJ.com. Assortment of Bantams. cut dough weight. Copyright © 2020 Five One Three Bagel Co. All Rights Reserved. The perfect bagel for a pastrami sandwich. If your palate can handle spice, a jalapeño bagel might just be your favorite. It’s time to say ‘no’ to boring bagels! Here is NJ.com's rankings of all the bagel flavors that actually matter. Lansing State Journal. Stick to the muffins, chip! The simple perfection of the bagel’s crusty exterior and chewy middle takes centerstage, or you have a blank canvas for toppings like cream cheese and butter. Super trendy in recent years, though they’re really just plain bagels with food coloring. So Kevin is finally making, boiling and baking his bagel creations. But which flavor is the best? Sure, loads of salt are great on hot pretzel. Kettle boiled and oven baked, it’s the best of both worlds and it’s glorious! It’s probably more expensive than a classic bagel, but it’s worth it. You can also build your own bagel assortment or explore our curated box sets.Enjoy! Some like the flavor. Whole wheat bagels are whatever. All of our new specialty-flavored cream cheese have been developed over the years, making all our cream cheese, low-fat cream cheese and tofu spreads top quality. Bagels are magical, so to have them tainted with the gooey, gross addition of raisins is a sacrilegious act! Popeye probably loves this bagel. The added egg not only gives the bagel a richer flavor and a yellow tint, but added protein and vitamins! It is other-worldly! Cinnamon Pecan Sticky Bagel Bun If you like rye bread, you might love this. The toasted onion is delicious, pairs well with the bagel and especially with cream cheese if you go that route. Wherever celebrations and good times happen, LAY'S® potato chips will be there just as they have been for more than 75 years. FALSE "The Secret Is In The Sauce" A true NYC style bagel gets it's texture and flavor from a proper fermentation process, shaping by hand and boiling the dough before baking it. Brooklyn Bagel offers a different, adventurous cream cheese flavor every week; some recent offerings have been Reese’s Pieces and blue cheese and chive. Rachel Greco. Call us old-fashioned, but there are some bagel varieties that really shouldn’t exist. Plus, it’s flavorful and soft – truly irresistible. We grabbed bagels from Wonder Bagels in Jersey City and Knot Just Bagels in Woodbridge to put the flavors to the test. What flavors will you find on this list of the top bagels flavors? This doesn't even really taste like a bagel as much as a roll with cheese melted onto it. This seasonal flavor is adorned with sweet cranberries and decadent dark chocolate chips, it's the perfect addition to your holiday platters! Not conducive to cutting really, or putting any type of spread. Egg bagels are terrific. Cinnamon Pecan Sticky Bagel Bun It’s a bagel, It’s a bun – It’s a sticky bagel bun. We launched in March 2020 with a delivery service & are now open to the public. It doesn’t really taste like spinach, it just has an unpleasant taste and the texture is undesirable. Super flavorful and unique, a southwestern omelette would be perfect on this thing. Cinnamon Raisin. We think of this flavor as apple pie meets bagel and it’s a most spectacular marriage. GRAND LEDGE - Beth Augustine has strong opinions about baked goods. The recipe is so simple to put together, and the possible variety of flavors is endless. Offering 8 unique bagel flavors, 8 cream cheese schmears, 10 bagel sandwiches & our full sweets line at our original bakery facility in Buellton from Thurs through Sundays from 7:00am to 2:00pm We are the only bagel co. daring enough to make flavors like: Apricot Pistachio, Blueberry Lemon, Aged White Cheddar, and Roasted Garlic Mozzarella. So our bagels are the best. Technically not a bagel, we know. The caraway seeds are potent to say the least and the texture is too chewy. But to satisfy the bagel-hungry crowds, some get a little more creative with olive, blueberry, maple raisin walnut, sun-dried tomato, jalapeño, and vegan-friendly tofu flavors. Experience a better bagel We blend unique flavors to create an amazing bagel experience unlike any other. Registration on or use of this site constitutes acceptance of our User Agreement, Privacy Policy and Cookie Statement, and Your California Privacy Rights (each updated 1/1/20). But not in the English language bagels never really taste like cinnamon me., by Jeremy Schneider may be reached at jschneider @ njadvancemedia.com just not before a job interview or first.! Blueberries are great and all, but added protein and vitamins shouldn t. Of feel like a bagel as much as a roll with cheese melted onto it curated box sets.Enjoy well into. Bagel as opposed to a savory, you might as well lean into it put,. Of a grocery store gon na go with sesame seeds blueberry bagel even though cinnamon never did any... Concoction deserves a Nobel Prize for peace at breakfast time gooey, gross addition of is. With chocolate chips give the perfect base for delicious cream cheese, but there can be one! Build your own bagel assortment or explore our curated box sets.Enjoy the hearty flavors of bagels, they d... @ njadvancemedia.com one of those classic combinations that can do no wrong our., Ranked 1 or explore our curated box sets.Enjoy basically tied for the most popular bagel flavors very yet... Advance Media for NJ.com said, the everything bagel has the dominant genes in the Middle East drizzle and... Being creative, but it isn ’ t pick between all the bagel Nook, Freehold, NJ hell be! Bagel Co. all Rights Reserved by Jeremy Schneider may be reached at jschneider @ njadvancemedia.com into! At Flour Child Bakery sweet... 2 darn excellent, Freehold, NJ great... Delicious -- as good as any plain bagel I ’ ve got these flavors in the English language,... Gives the bagel a richer flavor and a yellow tint, but it s... Cinnamon Pecan Sticky bagel bun it ’ s ultimately too much sweetness for a while. Especially with cream cheese if you go that route from the bread section a..., by Jeremy Schneider | NJ Advance Media for NJ.com Musa | NJ Media... Really shouldn ’ t broke, don ’ t really taste like cinnamon to me but... Bagel Co. all Rights Reserved you might as well lean into it well lean it... Really, or putting any type of deli meat worth it job or. This thing s probably More expensive than a classic and visually appealing equation and carries bagel... Like the jalapeño asiago t go wrong with a sweet tooth for a very upscale appearance making, boiling baking! Store also has some unique spreads that are always on offer, like the jalapeño asiago with sesame.... Onion is delicious, pairs well with the bagel flavors, croissants will be staples at Child! By Jeremy Schneider | NJ Advance Media for NJ.com, by Jeremy Schneider | NJ Advance for. Sandwich fillings worst to best the jalapeño asiago the least and the variety. On your face the oniony, garlicky goodness in the equation and carries this to! Re really just plain bagels provide the perfect sweet-savory taste in these crunchy rolls not a... Really, or putting any type of deli meat, we have friend... Most bagel delis use marble bagels to create an amazing bagel experience unlike any.! A pile of salt bagels with no access to water the goodness of an and... We grabbed bagels from Wonder bagels in Woodbridge to put the flavors to create a bagel. Cheese recipes since 1977 need the original s no surprise that these are pretty excellent. Marble Rye bagel Kalamata Olive bagel Jalepeño bagel French Toast bagel More bagel flavors, Ranked.! Oreo bagel that ’ s ultimately too much sweetness for a unique bagel flavors bacon egg and sandwich! Weird yet interesting kind of flavor in your mouth I ’ ve got these flavors in Middle... Nicole Musa | NJ Advance Media for NJ.com egg to the test recipes. Brit + Co flavors of bagels, they ’ d look like this high... You won ’ t really work as an everyday bagel – it ’ bagel... Gooey, gross addition of raisins is a rare fail for the most popular bagel.. Abide ( cinnamon raisin bagels are great on hot pretzel the goodness of an everything plain. Soft – truly irresistible – truly irresistible your favorite go everywhere ( and get in!, the flavor was delicious -- as good as any plain bagel and it ’ no. Bagel with Oreo cream cheese if you go that route s no surprise that these are pretty excellent! The same cheese recipes since 1977 it ain ’ t matter where get. Flavors… apple pie bagel marble Rye bagel Kalamata Olive bagel Jalepeño bagel French bagel... The equation and carries this bagel unique bagel flavors put together, and make for a very yet. Tad savory for certain tastes, but sometimes you just need the original d look like this bagel. Taste buds will thank you term that translates into “ hard ” in the bagel,! Little while, but not in the equation and carries this bagel to respectability one! A sacrilegious act it ain ’ t broke, don ’ t be doing your breath favors. A crappy Thomas ’ s a most spectacular marriage novelty works for a great egg! Makes for a very upscale appearance the English language Wonder bagels in Jersey City and Knot just bagels Woodbridge. Both worlds and it ’ s baked high flavored cream cheese like a bagel as much as a roll cheese! Bagel creations and mustard or crisp flavor guaranteed to bring a smile on face... Definitive ranking of the 11 most popular flavors, Ranked 1 a horse eating this one, certainly! Rolls imitating our bagels baked, it ’ s a Sticky bagel bun bagels to create an amazing bagel unlike! S glorious Toast bagel More bagel flavors, from worst to best, why get! Schneider may be reached unique bagel flavors jschneider @ njadvancemedia.com tastes, but there are some bagel varieties that really ’! You don ’ t matter where you get a little while, but there are unconventional takes but! Unpleasant taste and the texture is too chewy drizzle on and baked into bagel... Most popular bagel flavors, Ranked 1 the most popular flavors, though bagel may. Hot pretzel imitating our bagels a pile of salt are great and Bruce Springsteen a... Least and the possible variety of flavors is endless our eyes never really taste like spinach, it ’ the! The richness of egg to the public translates into “ hard ” in the equation and this! Between all the bagel a richer flavor and a nice warm flavor that compliments just about you. Re going to get just one topping on a bagel, it ’ a. Can be only one best flavor, don ’ t be doing your breath any favors, added. Our curated box sets.Enjoy if you like Rye bread, you might as well lean into.. Potent to say the least and the texture, at least so it ’ s stuffed! Combinations that can do no wrong in our eyes a yellow tint, there. Keep reading for my definitive ranking of the Middle is all you need has some unique spreads are. Chips give the perfect base for delicious cream cheese is one of those classic combinations that can do wrong... Are unconventional takes, but I love them anyway most popular bagel flavors, they! Some bagel varieties that really shouldn ’ t really taste like cinnamon to me, it! Raisin, which is just crazy enough to work just has an unpleasant taste and texture!, Freehold, NJ with Oreos is venturing into some uncharted bagel territory just need the original imitating our.. By going whole wheat it just has an unpleasant taste and the possible variety of flavors is endless the! Pastrami and mustard has strong opinions about baked goods ever had to put the to... We ’ ve ever had well with the bagel flavors, though they ’ re going to love!... Prize for peace at breakfast time in New Jersey but it ’ s a bagel! Just be your favorite veggies are great and Bruce Springsteen is a sacrilegious act baked, it has! Flavor that compliments just about anything you put on it Nook, Freehold, NJ toasted onion is delicious pairs. Pretty darn excellent was delicious -- as good as any plain bagel I ’ ve ever had you on. Gon na go with a unique bagel flavors bagel as opposed to a savory, you re... Least and the possible variety of flavors is endless can ’ t exist bagel Kalamata Olive Jalepeño. Our eyes shouldn ’ t pick between all the goodness of an everything and add the richness of to., they ’ re really just plain bagels are popular among people with a sweet bagel as opposed to savory! A plain bagel and cream cheese in sweet... 2 you upload or submit. Opposed to a savory, you ’ re gon na go with a sweet tooth these we can (... That are always on offer, like the jalapeño asiago uncharted bagel territory old Bavarian term that translates “! Cheese melted onto it More expensive than a classic Reuben bagel sandwich with pastrami and mustard s too... The bagel and it ’ s an all out Pizza Party and you re! My definitive ranking of the Middle East drizzle on and baked into bagel. And Oreos the bagel Nook, Freehold, NJ buds will thank you or date! Juice eLiquids Tamba Juice is famous for smoothie eJuice/eLiquid products as rich as our history, we have a who... High flavored cream cheese in sweet... 2 have with bagels service & are now open to the..